home > report on operations> To the Shareolders
To the Shareholders,
In 2010, Rai posted a loss of 128.5
million euros (loss of 98.2 million
euros at Group level), with a
positive net financial position for Rai
(3.8 million euros) and a negative net
financial position for the Group
(150.4 million euros).
The result for 2010 has deteriorated
compared to the previous year, which
closed with a loss of 81.3 million euros
(61.8 million euros at Group level).
The negative results of 2010 can be
attributed to on-going economic and
financial difficulties triggered by the
heavy structural contraction of resources.
The adaptation of the per-unit licence
fee, in line with the long-term trend and
anchored to the rate of inflation,
determined an increase of 40 million
euros in public resources, and this was
partly due to the contribution of
compulsory collections.
This result was positively influenced by
the dynamics of new subscribers, which
is recovering after the decline that
marked 2009: paying users have now
almost reached the 16-million family
mark.
Following the significant drop in
revenues from advertising endured in
2008-2009 - amounting to about 230
million euros - 2010 showed a reversal
of trend, with an increase of just over
30 million euros, corresponding to just
over 3 percentage points.
Other revenues, those of a typically
commercial nature and agreements
with the Public Administration, present
a decline of around 67 million euros,
completely cancelling the improvement
of primary resources, this being partly
due to the general situation of
economic weakness. Almost half this
reduction can be attributed to the
strategic decision not to renew the
agreement for the supply of channels
produced for the Sky bouquet.
In terms of operating costs, taking into
account that - as in every other even
year - the 2010 income statement was
influenced by heavy expenses for big
sports events (almost 108 million euros
for the World Cup and the Winter
Olympics), the tendency towards a
reduction in expenditure was confirmed
- within a constant setting, thanks to a
combination of coordinated projects.
Actions to increase efficiency and
rationalisation applied to all corporate
areas and to the subsidiaries had an
immediate positive effect, creating the
conditions to permanently consolidate
the benefits.
The impact on the consolidated
operating result, the most significant
analysis dimension, highlights an
improvement - following the deduction
of the impact of big sports events to
make comparison easier, of around 130
million euros.
These results were achieved through a
combination of targeted and selective
operations which made it possible to
attain real and significant increases in
operating efficiency and to optimize
the level of utilisation of internal
resources, also thanks to the
implementation of more streamlined
and effective production models.
The income statement also benefited
from the stability of labour costs. The
managerial operations entered into,
including early retirement incentives and
the substantial blockage of retribution
policies, made it possible to neutralize
the impact of the renewal of contracts
and expenses linked to the stabilization
of employees with temporary
employment contracts.
The absence of the inspection of the
retributive component linked to the
reaching of specific targets/aims, due
to a lack of the necessary
requirements, also made a
contribution.
In greater detail, as regards revenues,
the cost of the licence fee for 2010 went
up by 1.4% (from 107.5 to 109.0
euros). This is a percentage which is
substantially in line with the planned rate
of inflation.
The policy for the annual adaptation of
the per-unit licence fee has been
confirmed on the same basis again for
2011, with a rise of 1.5 euros (to 110.5
euros).
The licence fee continues to be the
lowest in Europe for public
broadcasting companies and also
holds the negative record for
particularly high tax evasion, which is
estimated at around 25-30%,
compared with the European average
of under 10%.
A gradual alignment with the
European standard, with a consequent
recovery of significant resources,
would require a revision of the
payment collection methods, joined by
a strengthening of the regulatory
instruments designed to combat
evasion, which are currently blatantly
inadequate.
More effective actions to considerably
expand the subscriber portfolio would
help Rai in the pursuit of its mission as a
Public Service in a rapidly changing
context which requires consistent
investments in technology and
particularly in the products offered.
These actions would also have positive
effects on viewers, thanks to the
balanced distribution of the benefits
resulting from the reduction in tax
evasion, and also on the audiovisual
industry in general.
On the basis of the results of the
separate accounting for the 2009
financial year, certified by independent
auditors, the imbalance between
public resources and the costs
sustained by the concession holder for
the fulfilment of public-service
responsibilities amounts to about 438
million euros.
This imbalance falls to 337 million euros
after the allocation of the specific share
of the advertising revenue from the
programming.
The recovery of the world economy
recorded in the first half of 2010
showed the first signs of slowing down
beginning in the second half of the
year. The international macroeconomic
dynamics penalised the recovery of the
Italian economy, initially sustained by
higher international exchanges but then
slowed down by uncertainties regarding
the evolution of demand, with
particular regard to the consumption
component, which is affected by
uncertain employment prospects and
continuing stagnation of real household
incomes.
In this context, the advertising market,
following the general decline of over
13% in 2009, recovered almost 4%,
while television advertising posted a
growth of about 6%.
Moving on to the more specific setting
of the reference market, emphasis
should be placed on the huge change
in competition, characterised by
broader, more articulated, multilevel,
and consequently multi-dimensional,
competition between different
platforms, business models and
operators.
Competition takes place at different
levels: between broadcasting and
commercial platforms to adjudicate
audiences forced to abandon terrestrial
analogue television due to the switch-off
processes by technical areas: between
free channels and pay-tv channels;
between the operators active within the
two market segments.
In the pay-tv segment, despite the fact
that the predominant role continues to
be played by the satellite operator, the
competition between the two major
operators, Sky and Mediaset, is
becoming fiercer and fiercer. This is
having evident effects on the acquisition
of premium rights, which are absolutely
critical to success. This aggression in the
strategies used in the procurement of
sports and film rights represents a
potential threat to Rai's competitive
positioning as these are areas
traditionally covered by the Public
Service Operator.
As regards free-TV, the affirmation of
digital terrestrial TV - which is now the
platform most popular among users -
has brought about immense changes in
the service offered. General interest
channels have been joined by a variety
of semi-general interest and specialised
channels.
There are almost 50 in the ‘all-digital'
areas and this number looks set to rise,
considering the channels due to be
launched by the operators taking part in
the so-called beauty contest for the
assignment of the television frequencies
available.
The proliferation of new free semigeneral
interest and specialized
channels has inevitably led to the
division of viewing figures among
broadcasters and the types of
programmes on offer. This has
determined a natural contraction of the
broadcasting performances of the
general-interest channels.
The framework outlined is represented
by the evolution of the resources of the
television system, characterized by the
extensive growth of revenues from
access to pay TV and pay per view
services, which now account for over
35% of the total, and by the market
shares of collection of payments for
advertising. Mediaset showed a stable
performance, while Sky enjoyed a
significant increase and Rai suffered a
decline.
In the presence of a structural weakness
of resources and the need to strengthen
the products on offer, Rai has
developed the 2010-2012 Industrial
Plan with a view to maintaining its
presidia of premium products in order
to compete effectively within an
extremely complex market setting and
continue to occupy a leading role
within the television system.
The Industrial Plan is the response
developed by Rai to create balance
within the company, also envisaging
operations that will influence industrial
layouts, with discontinuous actions on
the outline of the activities supervised.
Rai is currently engaged in
implementing that envisaged by the
Industrial Plan, developing the
operational and detailed projects of
the activities outlined, which will take
quite some time to accomplish due to
the structural nature of some of the
actions. Several important points
relating to simplifying the Group's
corporate structure are almost
completed.
The incorporation of RaiSat and Rai
Trade into Rai and of 01 Distribution into
its holding company, Rai Cinema, will
follow, before the end of the summer,
that of RaiNet into the Parent Company.
On the strength of its strategic
address/industrial tool and the television offering plan, both of which are
scheduled to be implemented over the
long term, Rai is pursuing its mission to
offer all users access to the broadest
and most articulated offering of free
broadcasts, achieving excellent viewing
figures across the various reference
audiences. In the all-digital areas the
offer currently consists of 14 channels,
one of which in HD: RaiUno, RaiDue,
RaiTre, Rai 4, Rai 5, Rai Premium, Rai
Movie, Rai Storia, Rai YoYo, Rai Gulp,
Rai News, Rai Sport 1, Rai Sport 2 and
Rai HD.
Rai is confirming and strengthening its
role as leading national broadcaster. In
terms of broadcasting performance, this
lead is further accentuated by the
contribution of the new specialised offer.
In addition to digital terrestrial platform,
Rai is also present on all the main
consolidated and emerging platforms on
the market.
With a complementary role, both for
territorially margin areas or those
penalised by possible reception
difficulties and in order to fulfil the
obligations imposed by the Institutions
with regard to technological and
competitive neutrality, Rai has set up,
in conjunction with Mediaset and
Telecom Italia Media, the first free
satellite platform, Tivù Sat, offering
complete broadcasting services,
without the blackout of any
programme within the whole bouquet
available on the DTT network in the
all-digital areas. This offering has
continued to evolve since its launch in
the middle of 2009 and now has
about 50 domestic and international
channels.
The development of DTT in compliance
with the calendar for the switch-off by
technical areas requires a consistent
financial commitment, starting with that
8 REPORT ON OPERATIONS
for the construction of the network
infrastructure: a technical investment
which, by the time it has been
completed, will have absorbed resources
of about 400 million euros, much of this
being concentrated in 2011-2012, as
well as significant commitments and
investments in the area of contents to
expand the offering.
Rai will have to face this considerable
investment programme without the
support or with only the marginal
support of public funding taking into
account the specific role of the
concession holder and its particular
network configuration, in a market
phase which continues to be difficult.
The insufficiency of resources from the
licence fee is joined by continuing
uncertainties relating to the dynamics
of advertising revenues. The general
weakness of advertising, while
conditioned by the on-going negativity
of the macro economic situation,
seems to present structural
characteristics, partly deriving from the
expansion of investment alternatives
available to those placing adverts and
the more targeted proliferation
possibilities offered by advertising
campaigns available on other
channels.
In this context, the outlook for 2011 -
which has the possibility to benefit from
improvements due to further actions to
rationalize expenditure, enabled by
stricter cost reduction policies, the
implementation of certain actions
included in the Industrial Plan and the absence of big
sports events - is much better than it was
for 2010, and should make it possible
to achieve a substantial breakeven.
The extent of the improvement will
depend on the performance of the
advertising variable.
Due to the orientation expressed in
certain legal provisions, during 2010 Rai
became eligible for qualification as a
public legal organization, with the
consequential need to apply the
instructions envisaged in the Code that
regulates public contracts for
employment, services and supplies.
Consequently, Rai - operating in a
situation in which it has to compete on
a highly competitive market - is
required, in order to satisfy its
requirements, and therefore for the
selection of its contractors, to observe
the principles and public procedures
envisaged by the Code, allowing for all
the exemptions and simplifications
envisaged by the regulations,
particularly in consideration of the
prerogatives and characteristics of the
television business.
The Public Service concession holder
operates in the awareness of the fact
that it belongs to the country. It
endeavours to interpret the country's
needs and hopes, translating them into
a rich and varied proposal, always
observing a very high level of quality,
right across the board. It will continue to
do so, maintaining the exclusive free
nature that has always distinguished its
mission and on which the particular
responsibility of the Public Service is
based, having been effectively
conceived and addressed at all citizensusers.
Everyone knows that Rai accompanied
the country's growth in the analogue
sector and it nourishes hopes, which
are already being partly fulfilled by the
early results and acknowledgements,
that it can play an important role in
the digital world too, where the
increase in the offering risks limiting
the growth in overall reliability of the
proposals.
At this point, we would like to reiterate
that written in last year's report.
The substantial belonging to the
Institutions of our country, as an entity
which performs a fundamental public
mission on behalf of the country,
subjects Rai to a series of increasingly
severe addresses, directives and
restrictions, which establish the details
of the area of activity and, at least
partially, the methods used to
accomplish it.
Every three years, Rai and the Ministry of
Economic Development draw up the
Service Agreement, an ‘operating
charter' which, on the basis of EU and
national legislation, established the
details of the single tasks that the
concession holder has to perform.
An Agreement which must comply with
the preliminary guidelines established by
the Italian Communications Authority in
accordance with the Ministry of
Economic Development.
The Consolidated Law on Finance
makes express provision for a
mechanism to guarantee the economic
equilibrium of the concession holder,
acknowledging that public resources
must equate to the costs sustained for
the performance of the activities
delegated to it.
This legal order has not been respected
up to now, causing enormous damage
to Rai, year after year.
If the principle of proportionality
between costs and resources had been
respected, Rai could have had income
for over 1.3 billion euros in 2005-2009.
Even without the results of separate
accounting, the instrument that certifies
the deficit of public resources, Rai
endures a deduction of resources which
is unequalled in other European countries, due to the aforementioned
anomalous extent of licence fee evasion.
The reduced annual income for Rai can
be quantified at about 500 million
euros.
It is obvious therefore that, if this evasion
were to be drastically reduced, the
imbalance that emerges structurally from
the separate annual accounts would be
resolved. This would guarantee the legal
required proportionality between Public
Service resources and costs.
The acknowledgement of public
resources to Rai in an appropriate
amount would have generally positive
effects: on the comprehensive
prospective balance of market
resources, on the audiovisual industry,
on the concession holder's capacity to
improve its focus on the pursuit of the
Public Service mission with a further
advantage for the overall quality of
programming.
Rai therefore believes that the recovery
of the accounts and of a sustainable
economic balance, as well as the
restoration of a solid financial situation,
require - not only for every possible
initiative to lever costs dynamics, in line
with the Industrial Plan - but also a
decisive intervention on public
resources.
Indeed, the intensification of competition
and the consolidation of certain
technological and consumption trends
have excluded the possibility of the aid
guaranteed so often in the past by
advertising in relation to the modest
income from licence fees. In addition to
this, during recessions or weak market
situations, the more restrictive conditions
to which Rai is subject have always
amplified market difficulties, and this
despite recent positive publishing
performances.
The maintenance of the structure of the
layouts and area of activity, in relation to
which the independence of Rai is bound
to the decisions made by the Institutions,
poses an obvious limit to the extent of
the benefits that can be obtained with
recovery policies concentrated solely on
rationalising costs, which do however
continue.
The need to make the licence fee the
main source of funding for Rai, with a
view to guaranteeing the prospective
economic and financial balance, is
shared and this forms a fundamental
basis for progress.
Indeed, the 2010-2012 Service
Contract recently signed between the
Ministry of Economic Development and
Rai contains - along with a further
expansion of the mandate assigned to
the public concession holder, induced by
transformations linked to the switchover
to DTT - certain important innovations.
The strategic importance of these
guarantees for Rai, which will have to be
applied promptly and meticulously,
suggests their integral proposition at this
time.
"The Ministry undertakes to identify, with
the involvement of the pertinent
administrations, the most effective
methods to contrast evasion of the
licence fee, suggesting appropriate
legislative initiatives and taking the
necessary administrative measures. To
this end, the Ministry undertakes to set up
a specific technical table, as soon as
possible, to be attended also by the
concession holder".
"The Ministry and Rai shall report
annually to the Parliamentary
Commission on the results of the actions
implemented to contrast licence fee
evasion and shall present a report on
the activities of the technical table".
"The Ministry and Rai undertake, on the
basis of the reports and proposals of the
commission or of evidence gained from
the separate financial statements, to
review this Contract, in order to restore
the best possible exercise of the service,
where the proportionality and adequacy
between Public Service mission and costs
and the relative funding, as the result of
this Service Contract, are significantly
altered".
In conclusion - with the support of
adequate public funding - Rai will be
able to ensure an even greater
distinction of its offering. It will be able
to make bigger investments in
innovation, to build a bridge that can
create a stable link with the new
generations, who use a variety of
technologies to access content, and it
will be able to acquire the skills
necessary in order to maintain a
balanced central role within the
communications industry.
Consequently, in the future it will be able
to represent what it has done so far for
Italian society: a place of understanding
and unification for the country's civil and
economic growth.